Which franchise made out best from 4 team trade?
Friday, July 10th, 2009Prior to the recent transaction between the Raptors [Bryan Colangelo], Mavericks [Donnie Nelson], Magic [Otis Smith & Dave Twardzik] and Grizzlies [Chris Wallace], this is what each of those team’s rosters looked like:
|
ROSTERS BEFORE 4-TEAM TRADE
|
||||
|
No |
RAPTORS |
MAVERICKS |
MAGIC |
GRIZZLIES |
|
1 2 3 4 5 |
Calderon Parker–UFA Marion–UFA Bosh Bargnani |
Kidd Wright Howard Nowitzki Dampier |
Nelson Carter Turkoglu–UFA Lewis Howard |
Conley Mayo Gay Warrick–RFA Gasol |
|
6 7 8 9 10 |
Ukic Douby Evans O’Bryant |
Barea Terry George Bass–UFA Hollins–RFA |
Johnson Redick Pietrus Anderson Gortat–RFA |
Jaric Richardson Young–R Arthur Thabeet–R |
|
11 12 |
Banks Humphries |
Carroll Singleton–UFA |
Richardson–RFA |
Miles Haddadi |
|
13 14 15 16 17 |
Delfino–RFA Jawai M-Bonsu–RFA |
Beaubois–R Ross Williams Nivins–R Stackhouse |
|
Carroll–R
|
|
TPE |
Adams $0.7 M Kapono $1.1 M Moon $0.7 M Solomon $0.7 M |
|
Dooling $2.0 M Wilks $0.8 M |
|
Coming out the other side, today, this is what they look like now, respectively:
|
ROSTERS AFTER 4-TEAM TRADE
|
||||
|
No |
RAPTORS |
MAVERICKS |
MAGIC |
GRIZZLIES |
|
1 2 3 4 5 |
Calderon Wright Turkoglu Bosh Bargnani |
Kidd Howard Marion Nowitzki Dampier |
Nelson Carter Pietrus Lewis Howard |
Conley Mayo Gay Warrick–RFA Gasol |
|
6 7 8 9 10 |
Ukic DeRozan–R George Evans O’Bryant |
Barea Terry Ross Bass–UFA Hollins–RFA |
Johnson Redick Richardson–RFA Anderson Gortat–RFA |
Jaric Richardson Young–R Arthur Thabeet–R |
|
11 12 |
Banks Delfino–RFA |
Carroll Singleton–UFA |
|
Miles Haddadi |
|
13 14 15 |
M-Bonsu–RFA
|
Beaubois–R Williams Humphries |
|
Carroll–R |
|
16 17 |
|
Nivins–R Jawai |
|
|
|
TPE |
Adams $0.7 M Kapono $1.1 M Moon $0.7 M Solomon $0.7 M |
|
Dooling $2.0 M Wilks $0.8 M |
|
|
DP |
|
|
|
2nd Rounder, Tor/2016 |
|
CC |
|
|
|
From Dallas From Toronto |
Legend:
UFA – Unrestricted Free Agent; RFA – Restricted Free Agent; R – Rookie Player; TPE – Traded Player Exception; DP – Draft Pick; CC - Cash Considerations
—————————————————
—————————————————
The Perspective From This Corner
|
IMPROVEMENT TO ROSTER SITUATION
|
|||
|
TEAM |
MINUS |
ADD |
NET GAIN |
|
MAVERICKS |
Wright George Stackhouse |
Marion Buckner Humphries Jawai |
Substantial improvement. i.e. Marion is the best overall player in the deal [+]. Period. Humphries is a serviceable Big [+]. Jawai is a reserve [0]. Buckner will be cut. Stackhouse was inactive. George was a reserve. Wright was a pseudo-Starter only. RESULT: ++ Gain |
|
MAGIC |
Turkoglu |
TPE $7.0-to-10.0 M |
Zero immediate improvement, i.e. Add Carter; Lose Turkoglu [0] … BUT with a gigantic CAVEAT. Now have $7.0-to-10.0 M worth of TPE’s [+], should they be in contention for a championship this coming season, in an effort to push them over the final hurdle. A Commitment To Winning It All. RESULT: 0|+ Gain |
|
RAPTORS |
Parker Marion Humphries Jawai |
Wright Turkoglu George |
Marginal improvement, only. i.e. Parker is a better player than Wright [-]. Turkoglu is a better clutch player than Marion [+], but Marion is a better player overall and a lot more athletic [-]. George and Humphries are even. Turkoglu commitment provides stability at #3/SF [+] RESULT: >> 0 Gain |
|
GRIZZLIES |
Buckner |
CC [?] |
Almost Zero improvement. CC plus a 2nd Round Draft Pick way, way off in the distance. RESULT: > 0 Gain |
The fact is, however, that the Cleveland Cavaliers [Danny Ferry] MAY have benefitted most of all from this specific transaction, as they subsequently gained unfettered access to Anthony Parker, the exact sort of complementary wing player they were searching for … to augment LeBron James & Co., in an effort to win their 1st NBA Championship.
Your feedback is welcome in the “Comments” section.



