Radical roster revamps rarely ‘right answer’, in NBA history
Friday, August 13th, 2010Neil Paine has now published an extremely interesting blog entry:
—————————————-
Most Personnel Turnover Between Seasons
Here are the (non-expansion) clubs since 1965 who gave the smallest % of their minutes to players who had been on the roster the previous season:
| Year | Team | Pct | Record | Top Newcomers | Prv. Rec. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2005 | Orlando Magic | 10.6% | 36-46 | Steve Francis & Dwight Howard | 21-61 |
| 1980 | Utah Jazz | 10.7% | 24-58 | Adrian Dantley & Ben Poquette | 26-56 |
| 2005 | Atlanta Hawks | 10.8% | 13-69 | Al Harrington & Josh Childress | 28-54 |
| 1998 | Cleveland Cavaliers | 19.4% | 47-35 | Wesley Person & Shawn Kemp | 42-40 |
| 1991 | Sacramento Kings | 20.3% | 25-57 | Lionel Simmons & Rory Sparrow | 23-59 |
| 2009 | Los Angeles Clippers | 22.5% | 19-63 | Eric Gordon & Baron Davis | 23-59 |
| 1997 | Dallas Mavericks | 25.9% | 24-58 | Derek Harper & Michael Finley | 26-56 |
| 1979 | San Diego Clippers | 26.1% | 43-39 | World B. Free & Kermit Washington | 27-55 |
| 1973 | Philadelphia 76ers | 26.5% | 9-73 | Manny Leaks & Leroy Ellis | 30-52 |
| 2002 | Memphis Grizzlies | 27.0% | 23-59 | Shane Battier & Pau Gasol | 23-59 |
| 1990 | San Antonio Spurs | 27.1% | 56-26 | David Robinson & Terry Cummings | 21-61 |
| 2005 | Los Angeles Lakers | 27.1% | 34-48 | Chucky Atkins & Caron Butler | 56-26 |
| 2004 | Minnesota Timberwolves | 27.2% | 58-24 | Latrell Sprewell & Sam Cassell | 51-31 |
| 1998 | Denver Nuggets | 28.1% | 11-71 | Dean Garrett & Johnny Newman | 21-61 |
| 2000 | Chicago Bulls | 28.2% | 17-65 | Elton Brand & Ron Artest | 13-37 |
| 1978 | New Jersey Nets | 29.0% | 24-58 | Bernard King & Kevin Porter | 22-60 |
| 1999 | Sacramento Kings | 29.0% | 27-23 | Jason Williams & Vlade Divac | 27-55 |
| 2005 | Houston Rockets | 30.6% | 51-31 | Tracy McGrady & Bob Sura | 45-37 |
| 1981 | Golden State Warriors | 32.5% | 39-43 | Joe Barry Carroll & Bernard King | 24-58 |
| 2000 | Orlando Magic | 32.7% | 41-41 | Ben Wallace & John Amaechi | 33-17 |
| 1978 | Seattle Supersonics | 33.2% | 47-35 | Marvin Webster & Gus Williams | 40-42 |
| 1978 | Buffalo Braves | 33.7% | 27-55 | Swen Nater & Billy Knight | 30-52 |
| 1982 | Dallas Mavericks | 34.1% | 28-54 | Jay Vincent & Allan Bristow | 15-67 |
| 1993 | Minnesota Timberwolves | 34.2% | 19-63 | Chuck Person & Christian Laettner | 15-67 |
| 1982 | Cleveland Cavaliers | 34.5% | 15-67 | James Edwards & Bob Wilkerson | 28-54 |
| 2005 | New Orleans Hornets | 34.8% | 18-64 | Dan Dickau & Lee Nailon | 41-41 |
| 2000 | Houston Rockets | 35.1% | 34-48 | Steve Francis & Shandon Anderson | 31-19 |
| 1996 | Philadelphia 76ers | 35.5% | 18-64 | Jerry Stackhouse & Vernon Maxwell | 24-58 |
| 1978 | Los Angeles Lakers | 35.7% | 45-37 | Norm Nixon & Lou Hudson | 53-29 |
| 1999 | Charlotte Hornets | 36.0% | 26-24 | Chucky Brown & Derrick Coleman | 51-31 |
—————————————-
which indicates that, since 1965:
i. There have been 30 teams change at least 64.0% of their player roster from the previous season … based on Total Minutes Played;
ii. The “Average Win Total” for these teams is approximately 30 per season [i.e. .366];
and,
iii. Only 7 of these 30 teams [i.e. 23.3%] have finished with more than 41 wins [i.e. .500+] the following season.
————
As you can tell from the comment [#3] submited by yours truly:
it would be very interesting to see what the results of Neil’s inquiry might yield, in terms of subsequent W-L records, if the parameters for examination were to be altered slightly, i.e. from a minimum change of 64.0% to >50.0%.
————
As far as the current edition of the Toronto Raptors is concerned …
These very simple stats might actually come into to play, if Bryan Colangelo [President/GM] is eventually able to trade Jose Calderon + 1 of either Reggie Evans, or Marcus Banks, this off season:
|
RAPTORS MINUTES PLAYED, 2009-2010, IF CALDERON + EVANS ARE TRADED |
||||
|
# |
RETURNING |
MP |
NOT RETURNING |
MP |
|
1 |
Andrea Bargnani |
2799 |
Chris Bosh |
2526 |
|
2 |
Jarrett Jack |
2243 |
Hedo Turkoglu |
2272 |
|
3 |
DeMar DeRozan |
1664 |
Jose Calderon |
1817 |
|
4 |
Amir Johnson |
1453 |
Antoine Wright |
1392 |
|
5 |
Sonny Weems |
1368 |
Marco Belinelli |
1121 |
|
6 |
Marcus Banks |
244 |
Rasho Nesterovic |
413 |
|
7 |
|
|
Pops Mensah-Bonsu |
107 |
|
8 |
|
|
Reggie Evans |
311 |
|
9 |
|
|
Patrick O’Bryant |
51 |
|
TOTAL |
|
9699 |
|
9771 |
|
RAPTORS MINUTES PLAYED, 2009-2010, IF CALDERON + BANKS ARE TRADED |
||||
|
# |
RETURNING |
MP |
NOT RETURNING |
MP |
|
1 |
Andrea Bargnani |
2799 |
Chris Bosh |
2526 |
|
2 |
Jarrett Jack |
2243 |
Hedo Turkoglu |
2272 |
|
3 |
DeMar DeRozan |
1664 |
Jose Calderon |
1817 |
|
4 |
Amir Johnson |
1453 |
Antoine Wright |
1392 |
|
5 |
Sonny Weems |
1368 |
Marco Belinelli |
1121 |
|
6 |
Reggie Evans |
311 |
Rasho Nesterovic |
413 |
|
7 |
|
|
Marcus Banks |
244 |
|
8 |
|
|
Pops Mensah-Bonsu |
107 |
|
9 |
|
|
Patrick O’Bryant |
51 |
|
TOTAL |
|
9838 |
|
9943 |
… which would, then, push next year’s team into the “>50.0% change” category.
———————————————————-
PLEASE NOTE: According to Neil’s research … of the 4 teams in the “>50.0% change” category from the 2009-2010 season - i.e. Toronto, Milwaukee, Minnesota and Detroit - only 1 finished the year with more than 41 wins [i.e. 1/4 = 25.0%]; while, the “Average Win Total” for these teams was a rather paltry 32 games [i.e. 128/328 = 39.0%].
———————————————————-



The reason 17 of 20 respondents answered with a “no” is because so many individuals in Raptorville do not really understand what’s required to win a championship in the NBA, including a high percentage of the team’s fans, MSM members and employees of MLSE, etc.
Blame for poor performance is habitually assigned to the wrong source concerning both the Maple Leafs and the Raptors and until this changes there will be no long term improvement on the ice or court for either team.
For example … wrong impressions concerning the Raptors include:
Chris Bosh is not a player who is worth a maximum contract.
Chris Bosh’s best position is Power Forward.
Chris Bosh is a poor-average defender.
Chris Bosh is not a player who is capable of carrying a team to a deep playoff run.
Chris Bosh is not a first-class leader.
Jose Calderon is a poor defensive player at the point of attack.
Jose Calderon is a low risk PG who is incapable of creating easy shots for his teammates.
Jose Calderon is a poor leader.
Andrea Bargnani is the kind of player around whom a championship team can be built around in the NBA.
Andrea Bargnani is a capable defensive player.
Andrea Bargnani’s personality and specific skill-set at the position which he happens to play best are not main problems for the Raptors.
Andrea Bargnani is a top notch athlete as a Center in the NBA.
Andrea Bargnani is a top notch athlete as a Power Forward in the NBA.
Andrea Bargnani’s best position in the NBA is Small Forward.
Andrea Bargnani’s best position in the NBA is Power Forward.
Antoine Wright is a good defensive player.
Antoine Wright is the best defensive wing player on the Raptors.
Antoine Wright is an out-spoken player who qualifies as a leader based on what he has to say about the play of his team when he speaks with the media.
Jarrett Jack is a better Point Guard than Jose Calderon.
Jarrett Jack is a solid offensive player.
Jarrett Jack is a solid defensive player.
Jarrett Jack has the type of personality around whom a contending team can be built in the NBA.
Hedo Turkoglu is a top notch SF in the NBA who deserved a $50.0 M contract last summer as an UFA.
Hedo Turkoglu is the type of defensive player who can thrive as a teammate of players like Chris Bosh, Jose Calderon and Andrea Bargnani.
Reggie Evans is the type of player who can bring a sense of toughness to the team he plays for in the NBA, at this stage of his career.
Marco Belinelli has a scorer’s mentality and is best used as an Off Guard in the NBA.
DeMar DeRozan is not a better NBA player than Antoine Wright and/or Sonny Weems.
Marcus Banks is not a better back-up PG than Jarrett Jack.
etc., etc., etc.
The actual list is almost endless.
Until these types of misperceptions are changed in the minds of many around Raptorville … this organization will continue to under-achieve on a consistent basis.
==========