An accurate understanding of what exactly is going on these days in Raptorville is not arrived at easily for many of the team’s rabid fans who are active participants in the on-line hoops community. Amidst the general euphoria that has taken hold in the aftermath of last week’s seemingly stunning 4-team trade extravaganza with Dallas, Orlando and Memphis … which netted the Raptors:
* Hedo Turkoglu [F, Orlando, UFA]
* Antoine Wright [G-F, Dallas, expiring contract this coming season]
* Devean George [G-F, Dallas, expiring contract this coming season], and
* Preserved their right to use the Mid Level Exception [MLE], the Low Level Exception [LLE], and exercise their [Larry] Bird Rights towards resigning their own Unrestricted Free Agents [UFA]
at the expense of:
* Shawn Marion [Sign & Trade with Orlando, UFA]
* Kris Humphries [trade with Dallas; injured much of last season]
* Nathan Jawai [trade with Dallas; disabled much of last season]
* 2nd Round Draft Pick/2016 [trade with Dallas]
* Cash Considerations [trade with Dallas]
The stark reality of this team’s current situation is perhaps best reflected in the bright lights of the following 5 observations:
PART ONE
The post-trade outlook for the Raptors which was first put together by “Dave” [nbaroundtable, Thu July 9], extolling the possible virtues:
Where do the Raptors go from here?
PART TWO
The specific comment which “Dave” then left in a different thread on his blog, later that same afternoon, indicating his actual thoughts on their chances to succeed with their current roster configuration:
———-
Four team trade: Shawn Marion to Dallas
2011/12
This is the Raptors fail safe option. When they fail, and they will fail, they need to have this option open to them and then use this option.
This means no extra contracts that last beyond two years. I will dislike pretty much any contract that goes beyond two seasons. As long as the contract is than two seasons, spending that money doesn’t bother me in the slightest.
Dead End
The Raptors are going nowhere, and they need a miracle to happen for this plan to have any chance of working out. The Raptors are going to run into [sic] dead end.
Now, it’s time just to sit back and let things play out. Things will not improve until Colangelo figures out Bargnani isn’t a cornerstone of this franchise … until that happens, there’s nothing else that can be done to put the Raptors on the right road.
The Raptors can’t get out of the corner that they’ve boxed themselves into, until Bargnani is moved on. Any aspirations for a title are on hold until this happens.
———-
PART THREE
The specific comment which was made on this blog [July 11, 11:35 AM], by yours truly, that addressed the supposed “Qualitative Improvement” of the Raptors current roster pieces in comparison with last season’s end-of-year squad, pertaining to the question of:
———-
Which team made out best from 4-team trade?
IMO, the Raptors have made upgrades in certain areas thus far but it would be a mistake in judgment to assess this improvement as being “a lot better“, just yet:
No BEFORE ADV AFTER
1 Calderon = Calderon
2 Parker <– Wright … AP is significantly better
3 Marion = Turkoglu … Turkoglu is NOT significantly better
4 Bosh = Bosh
5 Bargnani = Bargnani
—————————-
6 Ukic = Ukic
7 Kapono –> DeRozan * … cyclical due to draft
8 Graham = George … Devean is NOT significantly better
9 Humphries = Evans … Reggie is NOT significantly better
10 O’Bryant –> Nesterovic … Rasho is much better!
—————————-
11 Douby = Delfino … is different but NOT much better
12 Mensah-Bonsu = Mensah-Bonsu
—————————-
13 Banks = Banks
14 Jawai ? Barnes … jury still out on Nathan
15 Voskuhl = O’Bryant
Those who are looking at these changes in an excessively positive light are the ones looking through rose-coloured spectacles.
———-
PART FOUR
The Shifting Player Personnel Chart that was constructed by yours truly yesterday:
|
TORONTO RAPTORS ROSTERS
2007-2008 vs 2008-2009 vs 2009-2010
|
|
No
|
2007-2008
END
|
2008-2009
|
2009-2010
START
|
|
Mitchell
|
Triano
1
|
Triano
2
|
|
1
2
3
4
5
|
Ford
Parker
Delfino
Moon
Bosh
|
Calderon
Parker
Moon
Bosh
O’Neal T
|
Calderon
Parker
Moon
Bosh
O’Neal
|
Calderon
Parker U
Marion T, U
Bosh
Bargnani
|
Calderon
Wright T, E
Turkoglu T
Bosh
Bargnani
|
|
6
7
8
9
10
|
Calderon
Kapono
Graham
Humphries
Bargnani
|
Solomon U
Kapono
Graham
Humphries
Bargnani
|
Solomon
Kapono
Graham
Humphries
Bargnani
|
Ukic
Kapono
Graham U
Humphries X
O’Bryant T
|
Jack R *
DeRozan Y1
George T, E
Evans T
Nesterovic U *
|
|
11
12
|
Dixon
Nesterovic
|
Ukic Y1
Adams U
|
Ukic
Adams
|
Douby T, U
Voskuhl U
|
Delfino R *
O’Bryant
|
|
13
14
15
|
Martin
Brezec
Baston
|
Jawai Y1
|
Jawai
|
Banks T
M-Bonsu U
Jawai
|
Banks
M-Bonsu R *
Ukic
|
|
16
|
Garbajosa @
|
|
|
Delfino R @
|
Douby
|
|
W/L
|
41-41/.500
|
8-9/.471
|
13-25/.342
|
12-15/.444
|
?/?
|
|
Legend:
X – Injured; Y1 – Rookie; R – Restricted Free Agent; U – Unrestricted Free Agent; @ - Not on active roster; W/L – Won-Lost record; Mitchell – Up to Dec 3, 2008; Triano1 – Before Shawn Marion trade; Triano2 – After Shawn Marion trade; T – Acquired via trade; E – Expiring contract this coming season; * - Expected to sign soon as Free Agent
|
which shows the drastic player changes that have happened with the Raptors for each of the past two seasons.
PART FIVE
The glaring RED ALERT that was issued on Sunday by David Berri [i.e. noted economist, NBA "sage & soothsayer", author of The Wages of Wins Journal]:
Dashing Hope in Toronto
Not a Pretty Picture in Toronto
When we put the whole picture together, it appears the Raptors will employ the following starting line-up in 2009-10: Calderon (PG), Wright and/or DeRozan (SG), Turkoglu (SF), Bosh (PF), Bargnani [C]. Last season the NBA veterans in this line-up combined to produce fewer than 30 wins. So unless these players improve dramatically, or the team finds very productive players off the bench, it’s hard to see how this team improves dramatically. And that’s true even if Delfino returns to Toronto (although if Evans returns to what we saw in the past there might be some hope this team can get past 40 wins).
All of this means that
- Turkoglu will be seeing much more money in 2009-10, but probably far fewer wins.
- Bargnani will also see much more money, but it seems unlikely he is ever going to produce many wins.
- Bosh will see even more money after this next season, but if the Raptors don’t approach 45 or 50 wins (which seems likely) then it seems unlikely that the money Bosh is paid in the future is going to be paid by the Raptors.
- So it looks likely the Raptors record performance in 2007-08 will stand for awhile. In other words, if Bosh departs this team in 2010, then rebuilding will probably continue beyond 2009-10.
- And this means — assuming the Raptors don’t make any major change to this team — the fans of the Raptors will keep paying money to see a team that’s not contending for a title.
———-
Experience says that when disparate individuals like:
1. “Dave” [nbaroundtable] … who combines statistics with Basketball Acumen;
2. khandor [that's me
] … who relies primarily on Basketball Acumen;
and,
3. David Berri … who relies heavily on a statistical approach to the analysis of on-court production for players in the NBA;
actually arrive at a similar conclusion … which is essentially opposed to the GENERAL CONSENSUS that exists in Raptorville today … it portends of difficult times ahead for this team in the coming season.
In the best interests of the franchise, let’s hope that all three of these “stray birds” are eventually proven to be wrong in their assessment of the team.